The Lightning’s Nashville Loss Left a Clearer Question Than the Shootout: Can Their Defense Limit the Rush?
The Lightning left Nashville with a point, but the more useful takeaway from Saturday’s 5-4 shootout loss was not the shootout itself. It was the sequence that let the Predators turn a Tampa Bay lead into another tie—and a reminder of how quickly an aggressive attack can become a defensive problem.
The Lightning left Nashville with a point, but the more useful takeaway from Saturday’s 5-4 shootout loss was not the shootout itself. It was the sequence that let the Predators turn a Tampa Bay lead into another tie—and a reminder of how quickly an aggressive attack can become a defensive problem.
With the Lightning ahead 2-1 just 18 seconds into the second period, Jake Guentzel redirected John Carlson’s point shot for a quick goal. Nashville answered 27 seconds later. Anthony Cirelli could not hold the puck in at the offensive blue line; Adam Edstrom collected it, carried it the length of the ice and scored to make it 2-2. Tampa Bay went back in front less than three minutes later, but Nashville tied the game again before the second period ended. (nhl.com)
That is the sharper question coming out of the game: how can Tampa Bay keep its defense involved in creating offense without giving opponents a clean lane the other way? Carlson’s point shots helped produce two goals, including Guentzel’s early second-period finish. But after the game, he also identified rushes against as a concern, pointing to similarities between Nashville’s first two goals. This is not an argument to stop pressing forward; it is evidence that the balance deserves attention.
One turnover, a long way to the other net
Edstrom’s goal was the game’s most direct illustration. The failed hold at the blue line immediately changed the play’s direction: Tampa Bay’s forwards had been supporting an attack, and Edstrom was suddenly carrying the puck into open ice. The goal did not just erase Guentzel’s lead; it showed the cost of a blue-line mistake when the opposition can transition quickly.
The Lightning still generated offense. Carlson tied the score in the first period with a point shot that deflected off Edstrom, and his shot from the blue line set up Guentzel’s goal. Victor Hedman scored from the high slot after a pass from Nikita Kucherov, who assisted on Tampa Bay’s first three goals. Conor Geekie restored the lead in the third after Jeffrey Viel found him alone in the slot. Those plays underline why Tampa Bay wants defensemen and forwards contributing to the attack. They also make the turnover worth examining: the same pressure that creates chances can leave a dangerous gap if the puck gets through the opponent’s first line of resistance. (nhl.com)
This is analysis, not proof of a season-long flaw. One game cannot establish a trend, and the available evidence here is the game itself and Carlson’s postgame assessment. But the sequence gives the coaching staff something concrete to review: what support was available when Cirelli tried to keep the puck in, and whether the Lightning were positioned to contain the counterattack if that play failed.
The forward group can still make plays
Tampa Bay’s four goals also make this more than a defensive postmortem. The team repeatedly answered Nashville’s scoring, and the winning goal came only after Steven Stamkos tied it on a power play at 7:27 of the third. He collected his own rebound after hitting the post, then later scored the only goal in the shootout. Nashville goaltender Justus Annunen stopped all four Lightning attempts in the tiebreaker. Andrei Vasilevskiy made 29 saves in regulation and overtime, while Tampa Bay finished with a point. (nhl.com)
The other useful lineup question involves Pontus Holmberg. Two nights earlier, he had a career-high four points against Winnipeg while playing alongside Cirelli and Brandon Hagel. The Lightning’s own report said that was his first game on the wing with that familiar duo, and coach Jon Cooper described the arrangement as an experiment that worked well. Holmberg’s performance made a case for the combination, but one productive night was not enough to establish a permanent fit. (nhl.com)
Saturday offers a natural follow-up without settling the matter. Holmberg played seven shifts, according to the NHL game record, while the Lightning’s offense came from a different set of contributors. That does not show whether the earlier line experiment has been abandoned or whether Holmberg’s role is changing; the sources do not establish either. It does mean that Tampa Bay has a recent example of a potential forward configuration and a fresh game in which the group had to find offense through several other routes.
The practical decision is not simply whether to keep Holmberg with Cirelli and Hagel. It is how to use the team’s available combinations to support both ends of the ice. A line that can sustain possession may help reduce the defensive burden; a line that produces chances but loses control at the blue line can have the opposite effect. That connection is a tactical possibility to monitor, not a reported explanation for Saturday’s goals.
A point gained, a problem to work on
Nashville forced overtime when Stamkos converted his own power-play rebound, then won when he scored in the shootout. The Predators’ comeback means Tampa Bay cannot treat its repeated leads as sufficient evidence of control. But neither should the loss obscure the offensive response: the Lightning scored four times, and three of their goals came from different forms of attack—point-shot traffic, a deflection, and a transition setup in the slot.
The next meaningful measure is whether Tampa Bay can preserve that threat while making the failed blue-line play less costly. The question is specific, and so is the tape: the Edstrom rush began with a turnover, not a prolonged Nashville possession. If Tampa Bay can keep its defensemen active while providing coverage behind those aggressive plays, Saturday’s loss may serve as a useful lesson rather than a template.
Sources
- NHL.com, game recap: nhl.com source - NHL official game summary: nhl.com source - Tampa Bay Lightning, Holmberg’s four-point game: nhl.com source - Nashville Predators, game recap: nhl.com source
Worth a discussion? Pass it along.
Keep reading
Browse the story archive ↗More reporting, analysis, and stories from The Plank Report.
Beyond the Bay: The Lightning’s Patch Program Puts Its Community Commitment on the Jersey
The Tampa Bay Lightning’s latest community announcement is built around something fans can see on the ice but may not think about after the game: a jersey patch. For the program’s third year, the team and its partners have named two Tampa Bay organizations that will receive support through “Patch with a Purpose,” extending the team’s work beyond the arena and into local services.
Read the storyBeyond the Bay: Tampa Bay’s Cirelli Matchup Shows How the Lightning Can Win Without Brandon Hagel
Tampa Bay’s 3-1 victory over Edmonton on Thursday offered more than a stopping point for Connor McDavid’s season-opening scoring streak. It showed how the Lightning can reorganize their forward lines around a difficult assignment—and still get decisive offense from elsewhere.
Read the storyBeyond the Bay: With Hagel Out, Tampa Bay’s Depth Faces Its Biggest Test Yet
Brandon Hagel’s absence changes the shape of Tampa Bay’s challenge against Edmonton. It is not just a goal scorer missing from the lineup: the Lightning must reassign a forward who had been tied for the team lead in goals while facing an Oilers club arriving with a six-game winning streak and an elite power play.
Read the story