BUCS LATEST SCORELoading score…
NFL SCORES
Loading NFL scores…
INDEPENDENT VOICES. TAMPA BAY ROOTS.
FROM THE BAY.
BEYOND THE SCORE.
Other Sports / Analysis

Colorado’s First Night Without MacKinnon and Makar Offered a Blueprint—and a Warning

The Colorado Avalanche did not need a replacement superstar in Montreal. They needed enough players to absorb pieces of two stars’ work—and enough structure to keep one bad moment from undoing the rest.

Original editorial artwork for Colorado’s First Night Without MacKinnon and Makar Offered a Blueprint—and a Warning
Original editorial artwork; not a game photograph.

The Colorado Avalanche did not need a replacement superstar in Montreal. They needed enough players to absorb pieces of two stars’ work—and enough structure to keep one bad moment from undoing the rest.

Saturday’s 4-1 win over the Canadiens was an encouraging first answer. It was not a solution. Nathan MacKinnon is expected to miss a month with a lower-body injury; Cale Makar is expected to miss two weeks. Colorado scored twice in the first period, killed Montreal’s four power plays, and added a third-period goal with the man advantage. Mackenzie Blackwood stopped 25 shots, and Artturi Lehkonen had a goal and an assist. (nhl.com)

That mix matters because the absences remove more than two names from the lineup. MacKinnon was Colorado’s leading scorer, with 30 points in 20 games, while Makar had 23 points in 19 games. Coach Jared Bednar described their value not only in production but in the difference-making plays they create at five-on-five. His concern was that elevating players to fill those roles can thin out the rest of the lineup. (nhl.com)

The question, then, is not whether one player can imitate either star. It is whether Colorado can distribute their responsibilities without losing its ability to create offense or defend through difficult stretches. Montreal supplied an unusually demanding first test: the Canadiens entered with a 12-game point streak, and Colorado was on the road. The win snapped Montreal’s streak, but one game cannot tell us how the Avalanche will fare across the weeks ahead.

The first answer came from several places

Colorado’s opening goal arrived before four minutes had passed. Fedor Svechkov drove toward the net and scored from close range. Later in the period, Brock Nelson made it 2-0 with a one-timer from the circle as Montreal had a delayed penalty coming. The sequence offered a practical illustration of distributed offense: one goal from a young forward attacking the net, another from a veteran finisher finding space. (nhl.com)

Nelson’s goal also came with support from Lehkonen and Sam Malinski. That detail is more useful than searching for a single stand-in for MacKinnon. Colorado needs contributions across lines and positions: players who can carry the puck, arrive as options, and convert chances when the opponent’s attention is elsewhere. The first period did not erase the missing star power, but it showed one way to avoid making every attack depend on it.

The Canadiens pushed back in the second. Nick Suzuki cut the lead to 2-1 with a backhand from the slot, turning a comfortable-looking start into a one-goal game. Blackwood’s work became essential: the official game summary records 26 shots for Montreal and 27 for Colorado, while the Canadiens’ recap lists 23 saves for Jakub Dobes and Colorado’s account credits Blackwood with 24. Because the goalie-save totals conflict across those team accounts, the precise figure is best left aside; the broader point is clear in the shared game record—Montreal generated chances, and Colorado kept the lead. (nhl.com)

There was also a significant lineup adjustment. Alex Gagne made his NHL debut alongside Brent Burns, who played his 1,600th regular-season game. A debutant and a veteran milestone pairing do not replace Makar’s puck-moving or minutes. They do, however, show the kind of depth Colorado must draw on while its usual defensive centerpiece is out. (nhl.com)

Special teams bought breathing room

The decisive cushion came early in the third. Lehkonen scored on the power play at 4:14, giving Colorado a two-goal margin again. The Avalanche’s official account describes him scoring from the low slot after getting to his own rebound. Montreal later appeared to make it 3-2, but review ruled out Alex Newhook’s goal because his stick was above the crossbar when he directed the puck. Nicolas Roy added an empty-net goal late. (nhl.com)

Those moments made the game more than a feel-good response to two injuries. Colorado’s power play turned an important opportunity into a goal, while the penalty kill handled Montreal’s chances without conceding. The official summary shows the Canadiens went 0-for-4 on the power play and Colorado went 1-for-2. For a team suddenly missing two major offensive engines, special teams can help protect the margin while five-on-five combinations adjust. That is a tactical possibility, not a guarantee: opponents will have more games to study the new combinations, and not every close call or reviewed goal will favor the Avalanche. (nhl.com)

Bednar’s stated challenge is broader than scoring. With MacKinnon and Makar out, he said, other players must take on matchups those two usually handle, and that promotion can create gaps farther down the lineup. Saturday’s win gives Colorado evidence that its supporting cast can contribute. It does not yet show whether the same group can maintain that balance against different opponents and over a sustained stretch.

A win, not a verdict

The timing adds context. Colorado finished its road trip with five of six possible points, according to the team’s recap, and the Montreal game was the first without both injured stars. The Avalanche have reason to value the result—but the next test is whether the structure holds when a game turns less favorably. (nhl.com)

The 2026 MLB postseason is no longer underway: MLB’s completed bracket shows the Brewers defeated the Rays in the World Series, four games to one, with Game 5 played October 28. With baseball’s title decided, this evening’s feature turns to a fresh NHL question rather than another Lightning account of Saturday’s loss. (mlb.com)

For Colorado, the immediate measure is not whether it can reproduce a 4-1 score. It is whether the team can keep creating offense from multiple lines, defend without overloading the remaining top pair, and get timely saves while MacKinnon and Makar recover. Saturday offered an encouraging blueprint: early contributions from different forwards, a composed response after Montreal scored, and a special-teams goal that restored breathing room. The warning is embedded in Bednar’s point: every player asked to do more changes the workload for someone else.

One strong first game can make the absence feel manageable. The coming schedule will show how much of that performance was a repeatable team response—and how much depended on everything going right at once.

Sources

- NHL.com, Avalanche–Canadiens recap: nhl.com source - NHL.com, MacKinnon and Makar injury update: nhl.com source - Colorado Avalanche, team game recap: nhl.com source - Montreal Canadiens, team game recap: nhl.com source - NHL official game summary: nhl.com source - MLB.com, 2026 postseason history: mlb.com source - MLB.com, 2026 postseason results and schedule: mlb.com source

BRING THE KREWE INTO THE CONVERSATION

Worth a discussion? Pass it along.

Q
Q

Independent Tampa Bay coverage. Football first, with room for the whole sports conversation.

More reporting, analysis, and stories from The Plank Report.

Other Sports

Beyond the Bay: The Lightning’s Patch Program Puts Its Community Commitment on the Jersey

The Tampa Bay Lightning’s latest community announcement is built around something fans can see on the ice but may not think about after the game: a jersey patch. For the program’s third year, the team and its partners have named two Tampa Bay organizations that will receive support through “Patch with a Purpose,” extending the team’s work beyond the arena and into local services.

Read the story
Back to the front page
THE MORNING WATCH

Your Bay.
Your inbox.

The stories worth your time. The takes worth debating.
Join the launch list for our independent sports newsletter.